Normal Distribution
nothing is called 95% until it has been counted
Concept

The half-Cauchy prior — where it appears

A prior on a standard deviation that is the positive half of a Cauchy distribution, with a scale chosen in advance. It puts most of its weight near zero but keeps a heavy tail, so a spread the data plainly support is not pulled far back towards nothing.

Named by 3 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Three priors on the spread, at a true τ of 0.5. The posterior for τ under a flat prior (mean 1.66), a half-Cauchy of scale 1 (1.32) and one of scale 0.25 (1.15). The three answers differ by 30% of the widest. The prior does visible work when eight groups cannot separate a small spread from none, and almost none when they can.

A prior on the spread

Integrating over the population spread means putting a prior on it, which sounds like the objection rather than the repair. The prior's effect is measurable, it is invisible where the groups are clearly different, and the reflex choice for a scale parameter turns out not to have a posterior at all.

fullbayes · Prior How often a trial that borrows its control from an earlier one declares a treatment with no effect a success, by the earlier control's drift. Fifty patients an arm, an earlier control of two hundred, a one-sided 2.5% threshold. Without borrowing the rate is 2.5% at every drift. Pooling outright reaches 73.1% at a drift of half a standard deviation. A half-normal prior of scale 0.05 on the between-trial spread peaks at 35.2% and is still at 31.8% at a drift of 1.5; a half-Cauchy of the same scale peaks at 11.0% near a drift of 0.4 and falls back to 3.4%.

A control borrowed from the last trial

A trial of fifty patients an arm can borrow its control group from an earlier trial of two hundred by treating the two control means as draws from one population with a spread between trials. With two trials there is one difference to learn that spread from, so the prior on it decides how much is borrowed — and its tail decides whether the borrowing stops when the two trials disagree. A half-normal prior of scale 0.05 buys 17.4 points of power and, at a drift of 1.5 standard deviations, still declares a treatment with no effect a success 31.8% of the time. A half-Cauchy of the same scale buys 13.6 points, peaks at 11.0% and falls back to 3.4%.

fullbayes · Prior How often a trial borrowing from 16 earlier trials that agree declares a treatment with no effect a success, by its own control's drift. Fifty patients an arm, each earlier control of two hundred, a one-sided 2.5% threshold. With 16 earlier trials, the half-normal prior peaks at 88.1%, the half-Cauchy at 80.7% near a drift of 0.6, and the half-Cauchy with a fifth of the prior on a vague component at 16.9%. At a drift of 1.5 the three read 73.3%, 25.5% and 3.7%.

A history that agrees with itself

Borrowing a control from sixteen earlier trials that agree with each other should be safer than borrowing from one, and it is the opposite. Sixteen agreeing trials estimate the spread between trials as small, and a small spread estimated confidently is a licence to pool: under a half-Cauchy prior that let go of a single disagreeing trial, a current control 0.6 standard deviations from a sixteen-trial history turns a treatment with no effect into a success 80.7% of the time, against 10.5% at worst with one earlier trial. Moving a fifth of the prior onto a vague component brings the worst case to 16.9% and keeps power at 91.0%, against 70.5% without borrowing.

fullbayes · Prior

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Hierarchical modelPriorPrior sensitivityError rateImproper posteriorPartial poolingStatistical powerEmpirical BayesFlat priorMarginal likelihoodPosteriorPosterior mean

All concepts