Normal Distribution
nothing is called 95% until it has been counted
Concept

Imbalance score — where it appears

The number a minimisation rule minimises: how uneven the arms' counts are inside the arriving unit's factor levels, summed over factors. It is defined on factor levels, so a continuous covariate has to be categorised before the score means anything at all.

Named by 2 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Where one rule becomes three. Every arrival in 200 simulated trials is put to all three scores, and the picture is how often they would send that patient to different arms. The range and the pairwise sum are the same rule at two arms and at three — for sorted counts the pairwise sum is twice the range, so the arm that minimises one minimises the other — and they part company at four, where the pairwise sum is 3(d − a) + (c − b) and the range still sees only d − a. The variance disagrees with both from two arms onwards, on 5.4% of arrivals at two and 27.0% at five, because the scores are summed over 3 factors and a sum of squares does not order the candidates the way a sum of absolute values does. All three are called minimisation.

Three arms and three scores

Minimisation balances a trial by keeping the arms' counts even inside every prognostic factor. With two arms there is one way to measure how uneven two counts are. With three there are several, they are all called minimisation, and they send different patients to different arms.

multiarm · Assignment A trial designed 2:1:1, and what two scores deliver. 500 trials of 180 patients, three arms, a target of 2:1:1. The shaded bars are a minimisation score that divides each arm's count by the share that arm is supposed to receive before measuring the spread; it delivers 49.9% : 25.1% : 25.1%. The others are the same rule with the counts left raw, which delivers 33.4% : 33.3% : 33.3% — the balance it enforces inside every factor level is equality, and equality is what it gets. The marks are the shares that were asked for.

Balancing towards unequal targets

A three-arm trial allocating two to one to one is the ordinary case, and a balancing rule built from raw counts does not know it. It balances the arms towards equality inside every factor level, delivers a third to each arm, and reports that it minimised imbalance.

multiarm · Allocation

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

AllocationCovariate-adaptive randomisationCovariate balanceExperimental designMinimisationMonte CarloPermuted blocksStudy designAllocation ratioDunnettInteractionNeyman allocation

All concepts