Normal Distribution
nothing is called 95% until it has been counted
Series

Power — the series

5 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. Power at an effect of 0.5 standard deviations. The curve is the non-central t on 2n − 2 degrees of freedom with δ = d√(n/2); the dots are 4,000 experiments run at each size. Reaching 80% power needs 64 per arm.

    What a p-value does not say

    The same p of 0.04 corresponds to a large effect in ten observations and a negligible one in two thousand. A p-value alone cannot be interpreted, and the number that makes it interpretable is almost never printed beside it.

    part 2 · testing
  2. Power at an effect of 0.5 standard deviations. The curve is the non-central t on 2n − 2 degrees of freedom with δ = d√(n/2); the dots are 4,000 experiments run at each size. Reaching 80% power needs 64 per arm.

    How many subjects

    Sixty-four per arm for 80% power at half a standard deviation — a power figure that could only be simulated, with nothing to disagree with, until the non-central t was written. Two routes now, agreeing to within the simulation's own error.

    part 3 · design
  3. The power trials actually have when sized for 80% from a pilot of 10. Four thousand pilots of 10 observations, each sizing a trial for 80% power at half a standard deviation from its own standard deviation. 55.9% of the trials have less than 80% power and 11.1% less than 50%; the median trial has 76.8%.

    The spread a pilot supplies

    A trial sized for 80% power from a pilot's standard deviation is sized from an estimate that is too small more often than not. With a pilot of ten, 55.9% of the trials it sizes have less than 80% power and 11.1% less than 50%, although the planned sample is right on average. Sizing from the pilot's 80% upper confidence limit instead leaves 19.8% short, at 1.65 times the sample; from its 90% limit, 10.0% short at 2.12 times.

    part 4 · planned
  4. The chance a trial succeeds against its size, when the expected effect of 0.5 is uncertain by four amounts. With the effect known, 80% is reached at 63 per arm. With the effect uncertain by 0.25 standard deviations it takes 113; by 0.5, 1268; by 0.75, no sample size at all, because the chance can never exceed the 74.8% prior probability that the effect is positive.

    The chance a trial succeeds

    A trial of sixty-four per arm has 80% power at an effect of half a standard deviation. If the effect is only believed to be about half a standard deviation, give or take a quarter, the chance the trial reaches significance is 69.2%; give or take a half, 61.4%. Reaching 80% then takes 113 per arm, or 1,268 — and when the belief is uncertain by three quarters of a standard deviation no number of patients reaches 80%, because the chance can never exceed the 74.8% probability that the effect is positive at all.

    part 5 · planned
  5. How much of a normal outcome's information survives cutting it into two, by where the cut is. For a small shift, a cut at the mean keeps 63.7% of the information, so the trial needs 1.57 times the sample. A cut at the top tenth keeps 34.2% and needs 2.92 times; a cut two standard deviations out keeps 13.1%.

    An outcome cut in two

    Replacing a measured outcome with whether it crossed a threshold keeps 63.7% of the information when the cut is at the mean, 34.2% at the top tenth and 13.1% two standard deviations out. A trial that needs 63 patients per arm on the measured outcome needs 102 cut at the mean and 185 cut at one and a half standard deviations. The responder rates that result read as a share of patients who respond — 50.0% against 69.1% — when every patient moved by the same amount; and a cut chosen after looking turns a 5% test into a 17.7% one.

    part 6 · planned

All series