What each rung is made of
Each pair of searches, over 300 draws, split into the two effects its excess is the difference of. The overlap is what the second search loses by having the first already run at its own answer; the interaction is what the joint search finds by moving the first off it. They subtract to the excess exactly, on every draw, because the pinned supremum cancels. Two disjoint dictionaries of independent columns read an excess of 0.000011 and are made of 0.000514 and 0.000503. A break paired with a dictionary of step columns has an interaction of exactly 0 and is all overlap. And a break paired with an independent column has an overlap of -0.004395 against an interaction of 0.002364, which is what puts its excess below zero.
Overlap and complementarity, separatedslider: draws in the ladder, 4 positionswide2 views
What else it draws
The same object, drawn to answer the other questions the essays put to it.
The control pair's two components and their difference, against how much each of its two searches can find, over 1200 draws at each dictionary size. Two disjoint sets of independent columns are additive at every size — the excess stays inside a standard error or two of zero throughout — and it is not because there is nothing there. The overlap grows from 0.000112 at two columns to 0.000870 at ten, a factor of 7.76, and the interaction grows with it, staying within a factor of two of the overlap at every size. Two searches competing for one residual sum share ground and find configurations neither has alone, in almost equal measure, and their difference is what the earlier field's scale calls zero.
Where it is used
3 essays draw this figure, each at the numbers its own argument is about, so the same picture answers 3 different questions.
- Two effects in one number Overlap and complementarity, separated
- What a zero is made of Overlap and complementarity, separated
- A split that depends on the order Overlap and complementarity, separated